From the Dumpster Fire
AtlasNo. 1Haul 002 ·

Fewer children, almost everywhere

An interesting paper by Michael Geruso and Dean Spears on falling fertility rates around the world. According to their data, 67% of the world’s population now lives in a country where fertility is below replacement.

Chosen and annotated by Bhuvanesh · words and plates by the machine, from the sources named; every figure in the words is one of the story’s facts, each listed with its method

1950200020502100EstimatedProjected02468Children per womanSouth Korea 0.72Niger 6.06Peak, 1963:5.312023: 2.25Replacement 2.1World 1.84
Frontispiece · Plate I
  1. IThe fallPlate I
  2. IIThe crossingPlate II
  3. IIITwelve countriesPlate III
  4. IVThe floorPlate IV
  5. VThe peakPlate V
  6. VIWhere babies are bornPlate VI
  7. VIIIndiaPlate VII
  8. VIIIWhy India keeps growingPlate VIII

Checked45factseach with its method

The principal figures

5.31
children per woman in the world in 1963, the peak
2.25
in 2023, just above replacement at 2.1
67%
of the world’s people live where fertility is below 2.1
2012
the year the world’s births peaked, at 146 million, in the UN’s central projection
0
of 51 countries that fell below 1.5 have come back to replacement

Movement I

IIt happened everywhere

Plate I · The fall

The world went from 5.31 children per woman to 2.25 in sixty years

In 1963 the average woman could expect 5.31 children; by 2023, 2.25, just above the 2.1 at which each generation replaces the last. 158 of 161 countries ended lower than they began. In the UN's projection for 2100, half the countries end between 1.58 and 1.89, and the world goes below 2.1 in 2050.

PlateIThe fall
1950197520002023205020752100EstimatedProjected02468Children per womanSouth Korea 0.72Niger 6.06The world’s peak, 1963:5.31 children per woman2023: 2.25Replacement 2.1World 1.841950200020502100EstimatedProjected02468Children per womanSouth Korea 0.72Niger 6.06Peak, 1963:5.312023: 2.25Replacement 2.1World 1.84
Total fertility rate: every country of a million people or more, and the world with the UN’s 80 and 95 per cent ranges. United Nations, Population Division, partly via Our World in Data.

Plate II · The crossing

Two in three people now live where fertility is below replacement

Japan crossed 2.1 in 1957, the United States in 1972, China in 1991, India in 2020. Each circle is a country, sized by its people: 83 had crossed by 2023, home to 67 per cent of the world. The hollow ones cross in the UN's projection; 11 do not before 2100.

PlateIIThe crossing
050100% of the world’s people67% in 2023China, 1991India, 2020EstimatedProjectedBefore1950Not by2100India2020China1991United States1972Indonesia2025Pakistan2080Nigeria2078Brazil2002Bangladesh2026Russia1967Mexico2016Ethiopia2075Japan1957Philippines2020Egypt2060DR CongoNot by 2100Vietnam1998Iran1999Turkey2010Germany1970South Korea19841950197520002023205020752100050100% of the world’s people67%China, 1991India, 202019501970199020101950196019701980199020002010203020402050206020702080209021002023Projected belowBefore1950Not by2100India2020China1991United States 1972Indonesia 2025Pakistan 2080Nigeria 2078Brazil 2002Bangladesh 2026Russia 1967Mexico 2016Ethiopia 2075Japan 1957Philippines 2020Egypt 2060DR CongoVietnam 1998Iran 1999Turkey 2010Germany 1970South Korea 1984
Each country of a million people or more at the first year its rate is below 2.1; area is its population in 2023. Above, the share of the world’s people in such countries. United Nations, Population Division, via Our World in Data.

Plate III · Twelve countries

Twelve countries, one scale

Each panel is one country against the world in grey, on one scale. The UN projects 7 of these 12 to drift up from where they are now and the rest to keep falling; by 2100 all 12 are between 1.30 and 1.91.

PlateIIITwelve countries
Children per woman on one scale, 1950 to 2100; the world in grey; the value is 202326South Korea0.72China1.00Italy1.20Japan1.2126Thailand1.21Brazil1.62United States1.62France1.6426Iran1.70India1.98Bangladesh2.16Nigeria4.48Children per woman; the value is 202326South Korea0.72China1.00Italy1.2026Japan1.21Thailand1.21Brazil1.6226United States1.62France1.64Iran1.7026India1.98Bangladesh2.16Nigeria4.48
Total fertility rate, estimated to 2023 and projected to 2100. United Nations, Population Division, via Our World in Data.

Movement II

IIIt does not come back

Plate IV · The floor

Of 51 countries that fell below 1.5, none has come back

51 countries of a million people or more have gone below 1.5 children per woman. None has returned to replacement; the highest any has climbed back to is 1.89, in Moldova. South Korea, at 0.72 in 2023, is the lowest of them.

To put it bluntly, history offers no examples of societies recognizing very low birth rates as a social priority and then responding with effective changes that restore, and sustain, replacement-level fertility.

Michael Geruso and Dean Spears, “The Likelihood of Persistently Low Global Fertility”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2026Matched word for word
PlateIVThe floor
01020304050Years after first falling below 1.50.51.01.52.02.5Children per womanNo country of a million people has come back up through hereSouth Korea 0.72The highest return: Moldova, 1.89Replacement 2.101020304050Years after first falling below 1.50.51.01.52.02.5Children per womanNone has come back up through hereSouth Korea 0.72Highest return:Moldova, 1.89Replacement 2.1
Total fertility rate of each country of a million people or more that fell below 1.5, from the year it first did. The scale starts at 0.5, not zero. United Nations, Population Division, via Our World in Data.

At South Korea’s rate

100adults

34children

12grandchildren

Arithmetic on one number, not a forecast: each generation is the last multiplied by 0.72 over 2.1.

Movement III

IIIWhat it adds up to

Plate V · The peak

The world’s births peaked in 2012, in the UN’s central projection

146 million babies were born in 2012. Deaths rise as the world ages, and in 2084 they overtake births, the year the world’s population peaks at 10.3 billion. The range is wide: by 2100 the UN puts births between 85 million and 155 million a year.

PlateVThe peak
1950197520002023205020752100EstimatedProjected050100150Million a yearBirths peak in 2012:146 million babies2084: deaths overtake birthsDeathsBirths1950200020502100EstimatedProjected050100150Million a yearBirths peak, 2012:146 million2084: deathsovertake birthsDeathsBirths
Births and deaths in the world each year, with the UN’s 80 and 95 per cent ranges for births. United Nations, Population Division, partly via Our World in Data.

Plate VI · Where babies are born

By 2100, almost one baby in two is born in Africa

In 1950, 12 of every 100 babies were born in Africa and 62 in Asia. In 2023, 35 and 50. In the UN's projection for 2100, 48 and 38.

PlateVIWhere babies are born
EstimatedProjected050100of every 100 babiesAfrica12Asia62Rest of the world26Africa35Asia50Rest of the world15Africa48Asia38Rest of the world141950197520002023205020752100EstimatedProjected050100of every 100 babiesAfrica12Asia62Rest26Africa48Asia38Rest141950200020502100
Share of the world’s births by region, estimated to 2023 and projected to 2100. United Nations, Population Division, via Our World in Data.

Plate VII · India

India went below replacement in 2020; its people keep growing until 2061

India's fertility fell from 5.73 in 1950 to 1.98 in 2023, crossing 2.1 29 years after China. The population goes on rising because so many Indians are young: in the UN's central projection it peaks in 2061 at 1.70 billion.

PlateVIIIndia
1950197520002023205020752100EstimatedProjected0246Children per woman012Billion people2020: below replacement2061: peaks at 1.70 billionReplacementWorldIndiaIndia1950200020502100EstimatedProjected0246Children per woman012Billion people2020: belowreplacementPeak 2061:1.70 billionReplacementWorldIndiaIndia
India’s total fertility rate against the world’s, and its population, with the UN’s 80 and 95 per cent ranges. United Nations, Population Division, partly via Our World in Data.

Plate VIII · Why India keeps growing

Fewer babies, more parents

In 2023 India had 115 million children under five and 128 million aged 15 to 19: the base of its pyramid has already narrowed. The bulge of young adults carries the population up for another 38 years. By 2061 the largest age group is 55 to 59.

PlateVIIIWhy India keeps growing
0102030405060708090MenWomen0025m25m50m50m75m75m20232061, projected0102030405060708090MenWomen0025m25m50m50m20232061, projected
India’s population by five-year age group and sex, 2023 and the UN projection for 2061. United Nations, Population Division.